There were several jarring switches in context in this book. My favorite
parts were how Aryl and the others live and try to improve their lives.
They are the first Om’ray to think about making life better for
themselves. Unfortunately, the other two races are not sympathetic to
that, wanting to stick to their agreement. Then they travel to Vyna, and
to visit the Tikitik, where cryptic messages are exchanged. There are so
many unanswered questions here. How do the tabs of the ancient Council
work? What in fact is the M’hir, with its Watchers and the links between
Om’ray? Where do the Cloisters come from? How many Adepts are left in
the other clans? And so on. I assume (and hope) that these will be
answered in a later series. Then we get to the last quarter of the book,
where things take on a completely different aspect. I absolutely hate
the idea of group amnesia, especially since it was never hinted at
before, and it actually changes their personalities. But the world they
end up in is very interesting, and I do like the way they take steps to
protect themselves, though I have a feeling they’ve gone too far. I put
most of my enjoyment in the first three quarters of the book, but I
suppose the story would have stagnated if the author just showed the
status quo. I’m up for a change, but found this one a little too
jarring.
Spoiler review:
I had whiplash throughout the book. All the places that we’ve visited in
the first two books, we got to revisit here. From Sona, which was the
most satisfying, to Yena for discussions with Aryl’s mother, to the
caves where Marcus found the remains of the old aliens they were
searching for, to Vyna, where we discover that the rock monsters are
baby Oud, to the Tikitik village (which is new to us), and then -big
surprise- we head out into space, into the Trade Pact world, where the
Sona change significantly.
The Tikitik describe the Agreement,
but it’s not clear how this came to be, nor why it exists. Why are the
Om’ray required, and why does it matter how many are in each clan? If
there used to be so many more Om’ray, why do the Tikitik and Oud get to
decide which clans disappear when more show up at Sona? It seems that
the Oud have been skewing the Agreement their way and towards the
attrition of the Om’ray for a long time.
I’d really like to know
how the birth tabs work, and how they can transfer an old consciousness
into a baby with no soul (I don’t recall how she got pregnant in the
first place, not having been a Chooser). I’m not sure how I feel about
the Vyna at all, except that I really hope they feature into the sequel
series.
By far, the daily life of the Sona, and their struggles,
achievements (like the dam and the cloisters), and the dealings with
Marcus were my favorite parts. I love reading about this culture. Then
Marcus is betrayed, and some of his associates try to kill him and steal
the artifacts. Aryl is able to rescue him, but not before all the Sona
Oud have been killed and in a panic, somehow all Om’ray who are able to
teleport end up in the Sona cloisters. This, of course, alters the
Om’ray count, putting the Agreement in danger.
So Aryl decides
that they must leave Cerci. And this is where I think most people will get
the hardest whiplash. As Marcus dies, he gives them images of safe
havens, and they pick one where he felt the most peace, and Aryl decides
on one. Her mother can’t make it because of her special relationship
with the Mhir, as she survived when her Chosen died. But the others make
it to this new world. And it’s a far cry from the primitive society they
left behind. Yet they adapt very well. They discover that their ability
to communicate telepathically, to teleport, and to influence certain
humans with a telepathic inclination, allows them to integrate very
well. They took the artefacts with them, so they trade and get enough
money to become wealthy inhabitants.
Not having read the
original trilogy, I don’t know anything about these worlds, which seem
to praise pleasure above all else, nor do I know the mhir’ray
relationship with it in later times. Aryl is funny as a fish out of
water, but she’s also very driven to protect her people, so while she
gets into trouble early on, it’s not hard for she and Enris to get out
of it.
Speaking of Enris, I just love the way their love is
portrayed. It’s entirely giving, and while there are small bumps, the
telepathic way they are connected allows differences to be resolved much
more easily than in our world.
I look forward to the next
trilogy, though I find myself longing for the sequel trilogy, where it
looks like we would return to Cerci, the Tikitik and Oud. In the
meanwhile, I’ll read the rest of the series in order, and get to it in
time. Thoroughly enjoyable!