I am getting familiar with this author, and can now
appreciate the stories more, given how I know the characters after four
books. I like the way she writes both the action and the politics, and
the love triangle is something I think she's going to string along for
many more books! A lot happens in this book, and all of it develops
various characters. I just wish it hadn't ended on a cliffhanger.
Spoiler review:
I like Kerrigan, and I like the various plots that are presented in
these novels. Blackveil is no exception. There is the anger Kerrigan
feels toward her father for the things he has hidden from her (like the
brothel and the piracy). There is her relationship with Estral (and her
music) and Alton (and the wall) and the King, and Estora, and the
Captain and the rest of the riders. Then we have the Eletians, and
Kerrigan's relationship with them, and her enhanced magical abilities
when she comes into contact with them. There is the King and Queen's
marriage. And we have the threat hanging over us of Second Empire, which
like Terry Goodkind's Sword of Truth novels, had been whispered about,
but the storm of war has not yet broken. The way this author writes, we
will not witness a full scale battle, but events from the side, from
Kerrigan's point of view. Or maybe new characters will enter, like
Grandmother. I suppose it is inevitable that Kerrigan only brought Mornhaven a year into the future back in
First Rider's Call, but it
would have been difficult to keep him as a villain if she had taken him
a decade or century later, which is how it seemed back then.
There is plenty of irony in the book, too. A prime example is how
Amberhill decides to be charitable, because it feels good, but he ends
up giving money that allows a man to rent a room for long enough to send
an arrow into King Zachary's chest -where the man wouldn't have been
able to do that if he'd been robbed instead, as he would have without Amberhill's intervention. Almost as an aside, Amberhill is hit with the
sailing bug, as proscribed by his dragon ring, which is apparently
cursed. He hires one of the pirates from the ship (seen in the
last
book), cleans the guy up, then rents various sailing vessels to get him
close to supposedly cursed islands in the northern sea. There he is
shipwrecked, and we are left in a cliff-hanger as to his fate, except
that a siren-type woman has found him.
The book starts on a quiet note, as Kerrigan visits her father and
aunts, delivering messages and confronting him about what she learned in
The High King's Tomb. It was nice to see her father, both as a recluse
and as somebody who has great responsibility. We see him again as Amberhill starts his voyage, working with his men instead of apart from
them. Perhaps as an offset to the piracy he committed when he was
younger, or just because he feels he owes society for his wealth, he
does many good things, too, like opening the halfway house for abused
women. I think Kerrigan mostly reconciled with her father, though it is
hard to forgive him. He even kept the fact from Kerrigan that her mother
had an Eletian moonstone.
When she gets back to the castle, she has to deal with mundane tasks,
like the Riders' accounting, and she continues with her arms training,
but she's also invited to the King's masquerade, being a special
acquaintance, and the only Knight of the Realm. Here, she feels
completely out of place, as is her nature, especially when she is dressed
up in a ridiculous outfit from a well-known play. The masquerade becomes
a theme throughout the novel, as she sees it several times while she is
in the Blackveil forest, and the tumbler's mask takes on a special
meaning at the end.
When she is selected to join the Eletians in the forest, she knows she
must go, but after her last experience, she is still terrified. As she
takes leave of the King, he reveals his heart to her again in just a few
words. The day that she enters Blackveil, Zachary is in a foul mood,
which is why he decides to go out on a hunting trip, and is hit with the
arrow that incapacitates him for most of the rest of the book. I'm
surprised Captain Mapstone didn't feel guilt about that, as a
"distraction" was her idea.
This leads to a very interesting twist, as several of the King's most
trusted advisors take it upon themselves to move up the wedding date and
have Estora be crowned Queen in case Zachary dies. The political
implications are well played, as there could be civil war if Zachary
died without a Queen. Complicit in this is Estora's cousin, Lord Spane,
who really wants all the power to himself. He blackmails Estora into
doing things she would rather not do, and insists on watching her
perform the wedding night acts, of which Zachary awakens long enough to
share. Unfortunately, Zachary also reveals his heart that night, and
Estora becomes jealous of Kerrigan for a short moment. But she also uses
Kerrigan's example from the last book, disguising soldiers as helpless
village people to trap Second Empire's Birch, who has been preying on
border towns. I wish we could have seen more of the trap, but I guess
there was enough to cover in this novel.
It's also unfortunate that we don't get to see the machinations Estora
has the Green Rider Beryl Spencer undergo, but it is very satisfying to
see Spane brought to vengeance at her hands, even if the details are
missing.
There is also more action at the D'yer Wall, which keeps the Blackveil
forest at bay. Alton has tried repairing the wall, to no avail, and the
spirits of the wizards that inhabit the towers can't help, much, either.
But then Estral arrives, Kerrigan's old friend, and Alton falls head
over heels in love. They become lovers, which makes Kerrigan angry when
she finally arrives there. But Estral is a minstrel, and her singing
helps mend the wall in various places, even minutely affecting the
breach. So when grandmother decided to "deal" with the singer at the
wall, I feared the author would kill Estral. But it is actually much
worse, as Estral loses her voice completely, it being transferred
magically to the young girl grandmother is training to be the magical
guide of Second Empire.
We also learn that something happened in the one tower they can't
communicate with- an Eletian Sleeper awakened, but is full of the evil
taint of Blackveil, and so the mage sealed it off from the rest of the
wall. Estral helps Dale and Alton to get through, and Alton eventually
manages to kill the creature, not knowing that it is an Eletian gone
wild and evil.
That is sort of foreshadowing for Kerrigan's travels in Blackveil,
because both grandmother and the Eletians want to awaken the sleepers,
but in different ways. Mornhaven has instructed grandmother to awaken
them with their taint from Blackveil, to wreak havoc on his enemy. The Eletians will rely on
Kerrigan, who can move through the layers of the world. The spirit of
the ancient Eletian queen protected a grove of sleepers in a snapshot of
time, and Kerrigan is able to go back to that time to rescue them,
reducing the number of evil ones unleashed upon her friends, and
delivering the good sleepers to Eletia in the long-ago past.
But first she and her companions need to get to the Argenthyne castle of
the Eletians of long ago. The journey takes many days, during which they
are attacked by various evil creatures, lose several of their numbers
(both human and Eletian), and their magical abilities are altered.
Kerrigan and a rider friend get separated from the group, during which
time he goes blind from his magical gift, and she hallucinates, getting
them further into trouble. Meanwhile Ard, the forester from Coutre
province, has been tasked by Spane to kill Kerrigan (as he learns
Zachary loves her), but he doesn't take advantage of numerous
opportunities, preferring that the forest take care of her. Eventually,
when he does try, one of the Eletians kills him first. I did find that
this part of the story was wrapped up too neatly, but I suppose some
parts need to be!
The book ends on another cliffhanger, as Kerrigan faces off against
Mornhaven again. This time, she is presented with a magical mask by her
masquerade tumbler, one that appears to give her power to reorder the
universe. Instead, she smashes it at Mornhaven's feet (how did she know
it would break, and not simply bounce?), sending her
companions back to Saccoridia and leaves her tumbling through space. She
is caught by the god of the dead, and wakes up in a sarcophagus of some
kind! I hope she is just in the tombs again, like where she hid in the
last book -but who knows? We'll have to wait for the next novel in the
series to find out.
With so many characters and subplots, the novel is nice and complex,
with intricate webs that are interrelated in some ways, but remain
separate in others. I like that kind of complex plotting, and look
forward to more of it, and the further adventures of Kerrigan, Zachary,
Captain Mapstone, Alton, and the others.